Skip to main content

The Answer to the Complaint(جواب شکوہ)







Comments

  1. SK23 June 2013 at 03:00

    The situation of Muslims was the same at time of Allama Iqbal or he just predicted the future by analyzing ? This question always comes to my mind whenever I read Shikwa , Jawab e Shikwa or his any other poetry.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Muhammad Talha Bin Yousuf23 June 2013 at 08:11

      Allama iqbal farmate hain ke wo jaga jahan unho ne shikwa aur jawab e shikwa tehreer kiya wahan un per roohani kefiat taari hojaya krti thi ke goya us wakt ke musalmano ke shikwon ka Allah Rab ul Izzat khud jawab dia krte they isi liye ye us wakt ke logo ke liye to thi he aur aj kal ke daur me to buhat zarori hai espacially Pakistan ke Musalmano ke liye.Allam sahab ne isi waja se wasihat ki thi ke unhe us he jaga dafnaya jae aur aj un ka maqbara usi jaga hai jahan jawab e shikwa tehreer kiya gaya tha.

      Delete
    2. Unknown25 June 2013 at 10:32

      SubhaanALLAH,,, nice answer...
      Besides the poetry contents and its meanings, All the rules and formalities of Urdu poetry are just perfect. look at the flow, balance and simplicity. His poems are still alive and relevant to our present situation. We still have lot to learn from His poetry.
      He is a Spiritual Leader for all of us.
      Recently I heard on tv, about an Iranian Minister who especially came Pakistan to visit Mazar-e-Iqbal and didn't meet any of the Pakistani officials. People from Turkey and other muslim countries come to Mazar-e-Iqbal to recite 'Fateha'. I feel others value him more than us(the Pakistanis)...

      Thanx for Posting this Jwab-e-SHikwa

      Delete
    3. Muhammad Talha Bin Yousuf25 June 2013 at 10:42

      Yes Khalid , the vision that Allama sahab had at that time is the best , i see this peom as very good suggestion to overcome today's crisis.He wrote poetry just like a painter ...when you see a painter during his painting you will never be able to understand what he wanted to draw but the last stroke of the painter reveals the real drawing out of the painting....so what this poem is all about is revealed in last

      Ki Muhammad se wafa to ne to hum tere hain
      ye jahan cheez hai kia loh o kalam tere hain

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

People with the broken heart

According to palmistry, our hand has three main lines. Heart line , Head line and Life line. Every lines shows a particular trend or situation from which the person has gone through, going or will go in the future. I want your attention towards the heart line. The top line that starts beneath the first finger , sometimes from between first and middle finger and sometimes from under the middle finger. This line describes the situation or destiny of the person that is related with his or her heart. What i have learnt and seen is that a person who has a broken heart has special type of heart line. The heart line having a small boxes on it , is facing a heart breaking period and in some books i have read that the heart line of broken heart people always dies towards the end. So if you want to see that the person has faced or will face the heart break check out the heart line. As a hobby when i read the hands of different people (mostly my friends) or sometimes complete strangers i...
14 comments
Read more

Don't Worry....Be Happy !

Along with the many bad things, the corporatism has largely increase the sadness or what psychologist says , depression .There was a time when the people were happier than they are now.Many people will oppose me but what i am saying is true.The expansion in the media especially the news casting media , people are much likely to be depressed.People will say that the media shows the truth ....whats wrong in that?Yeah i agree that the news media shows the truth but as we all know that today our society has negative more than the positive.I relate that with a example that the water sewerage system is also a truth of society and we can not ignore that but it is useful and bearable when it is hidden , if it has made open will it help society? No. Another thing which is important that by explaining bad to people we can't stop that bad thing but by preaching the good among people will increase the good among them. I know i can not change it by writing a blog but what i can do i will try...
18 comments
Read more

Thank You Sir !

I was very worried at that time , the college timings were going to end but i was not able to ask the question i wanted to ask.At last myself and my friend Arif were free from all the classes and then i asked him to go with me to ask that question.It was an afternoon in 2008 and i was in D.J Sindh Govt. Science college , completing the last year of BSc.The worry was that i just started the teaching and then i was stuck in a topic's basic understanding.The Topic was "Phase Angle" and i was unable to understand the basic idea behind "Initial phase angle".We met with few teachers to get the basic idea of the topic , one teacher said "it is impossible to define everything in Physics", one  teacher explained the mathematical definition and what one teacher said was flown away above my head.When we were leaving the department of Physics ,I saw him and thank God that time because i was sure that then i will have the right answer.I asked the same question fro...
5 comments
Read more